Exhibits are final, the list has been exchanged, and someone now has a sheet of colored labels and a stack of documents. Pre-marking looks like the easiest job in hearing prep, yet it is where small errors become visible on the record: a sticker covering a signature, a “Plaintiff’s 12” that the list calls P-12A, a video with no label at all.

This guide covers the mechanics of marking exhibits for a hearing or trial: sticker conventions and where they come from, where stickers go, cover sheets and slip sheets, digital stamps on PDFs, and how to mark multi-page, native and media exhibits so they match the exhibit list and the Bates range. For the list itself and binder assembly, see the exhibit list template and the hearing exhibit binder checklist.

What are exhibit stickers, and why pre-mark exhibits?

Exhibit stickers are adhesive labels that identify an exhibit by party and number so everyone in the courtroom can refer to it on the record. Commercial labels usually carry a printed party designation and a line for the exhibit number, and many add lines for the case number, the date and the clerk’s or reporter’s initials.

Pre-marking means applying those labels before the hearing, in the court’s format, so court time is not spent marking documents. Many courts require it by pretrial order or standing procedure. One federal district court’s exhibit-marking instructions, for example, say exhibits not numbered under its procedure will be returned for re-marking and that court time will not be used for marking exhibits.

What color are plaintiff and defendant exhibit stickers?

There is no universal rule. A common convention in federal courtrooms is yellow for the plaintiff or government and blue for the defendant, but courts differ, some supply their own labels, and some care only about prefixes and numbers.

Two published examples show how much varies even when the colors match. The district court instructions linked above use yellow and blue cover sheets and labels, numbers only, and assign number blocks to each side (their example is plaintiff 1–80 and defendant 100–180). One federal bankruptcy court’s pre-marking instructions also use yellow for plaintiff and blue for defendant, but plaintiff numbers its exhibits while defendant letters them (A, B, C, then AA, AB).

ElementConventions you will seeWhat to confirm
ColorYellow plaintiff or government, blue defendant; sometimes other colors or court-issued labelsRequired colors and who supplies labels
IdentifierNumbers for one side and letters for the other; numbers only with blocks; party prefixes such as P-, D- and J-Scheme in the pretrial order; prefix for joint exhibits
Sub-parts3a, 3b; 1-A, 1-B for groups of photographs or checksWhether sub-parts are allowed or each item needs its own number
PlacementFirst page, bottom or lower right; back of photographsAny required position
CopiesOriginal stickered set for the clerk; copies marked or unmarkedWhich sets carry original stickers

Numbering choices themselves (blocks, prefixes, suffixes for late additions) are covered in the exhibit list guide linked above. The rule that matters here: the sticker shows exactly the identifier on the list, in the same form.

Where should the exhibit sticker go?

Put it on the first page, in blank space near the bottom right, where it covers nothing. That means no text, signatures, dates, handwriting, stamps, letterhead details or Bates numbers.

  • Documents with no margin. Use the court’s cover sheet, or a blank leading page that carries the sticker, rather than covering content. The bankruptcy court instructions above have small documents stapled to a standard sheet with the label on that sheet.
  • Photographs. Label the back or a mount, unless the court says otherwise; the district court instructions above call for adhesive labels on the back of photos.
  • Charts and boards. Lower right corner or the reverse side.
  • Physical objects. A tie tag or a label on the container, so the item itself is not altered.

What is an exhibit cover sheet, and when do you use one?

An exhibit cover sheet is a page placed in front of the exhibit that identifies it: party, exhibit number, case caption or number, and a short neutral description. Some courts require them; the district court instructions above use colored cover sheets stapled to the top of standard paper exhibits. Teams also use them when a sticker would cover content and as the first page of PDF exhibits.

Example: cover sheet (fictional matter)

Harbor Point Supply Co. v. Delgado Freight LLC, Case No. 25-CV-01187
PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 14
Email chain between M. Ortiz and K. Bell re: delivery schedule, Apr. 2–4, 2025 (6 pp.)
Bates HPS-0004120 to HPS-0004125

The description matches the exhibit list word for word, and the Bates range lets anyone tie the exhibit back to the production.

A slip sheet is different. It is a placeholder page in the binder for an exhibit that cannot sit there: a USB drive, a video, an oversized board, a physical object or a sealed item. It carries the exhibit number and description and says where the actual exhibit is. (In productions, “slipsheet” also means the numbered page that stands in for a native file; see how to Bates stamp PDFs.)

How do you mark exhibits digitally on a PDF?

Apply the exhibit label as a stamp, header or footer, or as a cover page, in a consistent position on every exhibit, then flatten the file so the mark cannot be moved or deleted. A digital stamp follows the same placement rules as a sticker: blank space, nothing covered.

  1. Start from the final, reviewed exhibit. Marking a draft almost always means marking twice.
  2. Choose the method. A cover page avoids covering content entirely; a stamp in the lower margin keeps the first page intact.
  3. Match the court’s wording. “Plaintiff’s Exhibit 14,” “PX-014” or “Exhibit 14,” exactly as the list and the court’s format use it.
  4. Flatten and check. Confirm the stamp stays put, the text remains searchable and nothing underneath was hidden.
  5. Name the file to match. For example, PX-014_Ortiz-Bell-emails_2025-04-02.pdf, so sorting by name sorts by exhibit.

Digitally stamped exhibits are what you share on screen at a remote hearing and what you attach when exhibits are filed electronically; e-filing exhibits covers the PDF rules courts commonly set. Evidence Helper, for instance, exports exhibit-numbered, captioned PDFs that list each file’s SHA-256, which gives each exhibit a fixed reference before anything is printed.

How do you mark multi-page, native and media exhibits?

Mark the first page, number every page, and give anything that is not paper a label on the item and a slip sheet in the binder.

Multi-page exhibits

One sticker on page one, with page or Bates numbers on every page so a witness can be pointed to a specific page. Some courts set a threshold; the bankruptcy court instructions above require page numbers on exhibits longer than five pages. Fasten each exhibit the way the court prefers; the district court instructions above ask for staples or ACCO fasteners, not paper or binder clips.

Group exhibits

For a set of photographs, checks or receipts, label each item with a sub-number (14-A, 14-B) if the court allows sub-parts, and state the count on the list.

Audio, video and native files

Label the physical media (drive or disc) and its sleeve or case with the exhibit number, and put a slip sheet in each binder stating the file name, running time and where the media is held. Place any transcript behind the slip sheet. The federal AO 187 exhibit and witness list form asks for a notation of where any exhibit not held with the case file is located, which is the same idea. For the evidentiary side of recordings, see audio recordings as evidence.

How do you keep stickers consistent with the exhibit list and Bates numbers?

Treat the exhibit list as the single source of truth and generate stickers, cover sheets, tabs and file names from it. The sticker never replaces the Bates number: Bates numbers identify pages in the production, exhibit numbers identify items in the hearing record, and both stay visible. The Bates numbering guide explains how the two relate.

  • Sticker number and party match the exhibit list row, the tab and the file name
  • Color, prefix and format follow the judge’s procedures or pretrial order
  • Nothing covered: text, signatures, dates, handwriting or Bates numbers
  • Page or Bates numbers on every page of multi-page exhibits
  • Photographs and group items labeled individually where the court allows sub-parts
  • Media labeled on the device and the sleeve, with a slip sheet in each binder
  • Original stickers only on the set the court designates
  • Withdrawn exhibits keep their number; nothing is renumbered after exchange

Marking conventions come from the court, and they differ by judge, by courthouse and between federal and state courts. Check the judge’s procedures, the pretrial or scheduling order and the clerk’s instructions, and ask the courtroom deputy when they are silent. This is general information, not legal advice.

How CourtBriefly helps

CourtBriefly’s hearing preparation tools let your team link facts and working notes to the underlying records, assemble exhibit and hearing binders from the matter, and track revisions before anything is printed, so a late change to an exhibit surfaces before the stickers go on. When the set is final, you can release a selected package to named recipients with a manifest, an expiry and acknowledgment.

Start freeFree plan, no card