The text thread is Exhibit 14, the client swears every message is real, and opposing counsel has not said whether they will fight authenticity at trial. You could line up a foundation witness, subpoena carrier records or retain a forensic examiner. Or you could ask the other side, in writing, to admit the thread is genuine and let the rules supply the consequences if they refuse.
This guide covers how requests for admission work on genuineness under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 36, the response deadline and deemed admissions, the cost-shifting rule for unjustified denials, how to draft tight requests for message exhibits, fictional sample requests, what to do with the answers and how all of it feeds the pretrial stipulation. Many state rules are modeled on the federal rules, but numbering, limits and deadlines vary, so check the rules and orders that govern your matter.
What is a request for admission of genuineness?
It is a written request asking another party to admit that a described document is genuine, for purposes of the pending action only. Federal Rule 36(a)(1)(B) expressly allows requests about “the genuineness of any described documents,” alongside requests about facts, the application of law to fact and opinions about either.
Two form requirements matter most for exhibits. Under Rule 36(a)(2), each matter must be separately stated, and a request to admit genuineness must be accompanied by a copy of the document unless it has already been furnished or made available for inspection and copying. In practice, that means you attach the exhibit or cite the exact Bates range you already produced.
Requests for admission are less about discovering information than about narrowing what must be proved. That makes them a natural fit for authentication, where the honest answer is usually obvious to both sides and the only question is whether anyone will make you prove it. Remember the timing rule as well: under Rule 26(d)(1), discovery generally cannot be served before the Rule 26(f) conference unless a rule, stipulation or order allows it.
How long does the other side have to respond?
Thirty days after service, under Rule 36(a)(3), unless the parties stipulate to a different time under Rule 29 or the court orders one. The response must be a written answer or objection, signed by the party or its attorney. Rule 6(d) adds three days when service is made by mail, by leaving the papers with the clerk or by other means the served party consented to; electronic service no longer adds time.
If no timely answer or objection is served, the matter is admitted. Under Rule 36(b), an admitted matter is conclusively established for the pending action unless the court, on motion, permits the admission to be withdrawn or amended. Courts weigh whether withdrawal would promote the presentation of the merits and whether it would prejudice the requesting party in maintaining or defending the action on the merits.
What must a response to a request for admission say?
It must admit, specifically deny or explain in detail why the party cannot truthfully admit or deny. Rule 36(a)(4) sets the rest of the standard:
- A denial must fairly respond to the substance of the request.
- When good faith requires qualifying an answer or denying only part of a matter, the answer must specify the part admitted and qualify or deny the rest.
- Lack of knowledge is a valid answer only if the party states it made a reasonable inquiry and the information it knows or can readily obtain is insufficient.
- Under Rule 36(a)(5), the grounds for any objection must be stated, and a party may not object solely because the request presents a genuine issue for trial.
If an answer or objection looks evasive, Rule 36(a)(6) lets the requesting party move to determine its sufficiency. The court can order an answer, deem the matter admitted or order an amended answer.
What happens if they deny a document that turns out to be genuine?
The requesting party can ask the court to make them pay for the proof. Under Federal Rule 37(c)(2), if a party fails to admit what was requested and the requesting party later proves the document genuine, the requesting party may move for the reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, incurred in making that proof. The court must so order unless the request was held objectionable, the admission sought was of no substantial importance, the party failing to admit had reasonable ground to believe it might prevail, or there was other good reason for the failure.
Two practical points follow. First, a narrow, precise request leaves less room for the “reasonable ground to believe it might prevail” exception than a sprawling one. Second, if a genuineness request is denied, keep the proof costs separately identifiable from the start: time spent preparing a foundation witness, subpoena costs and any examiner’s fees. A cost motion is much easier to support from clean records.
How do you draft requests for admission for text message exhibits?
Treat every request as a single, unambiguous question about a single, identifiable exhibit. A sequence that works for message threads:
- Produce the exhibit first. Render the thread as a paginated, Bates-numbered log, produce it and keep the source manifest. The text message exhibit format guide covers headers, timestamps and attachments.
- Define your terms once. A short definitions section for “Exhibit A,” “the Number” and “the Thread” keeps each request short and stops quibbles about what was meant.
- One document per request. Rule 36(a)(2) requires each matter to be separately stated. Bundling ten exhibits into one request invites a partial denial nobody can parse.
- Identify the exhibit precisely. Give the exhibit letter, Bates range, date range and participants, and attach the copy. A consistent Bates prefix makes the reference unmistakable.
- Separate genuineness from authorship and completeness. Whether the copy is genuine, whether the party used the number, whether the party sent the messages and whether the exhibit omits anything are four different requests. The completeness request is the one most likely to be qualified, so keep it apart from the others.
- Keep the wording neutral. “Threatening messages” or “admit you harassed” will draw objections. Describe the document, not what it proves.
Requests for admission work alongside the other foundation tools in our guide to authenticating text messages under Rule 901, including deposition questions and pretrial disclosure objections.
What do sample requests for admission look like?
Example (fictional matter)
In Harlow v. Benning, a dispute over a home renovation, plaintiff’s counsel produced the text thread between Dana Harlow and the contractor, Marcus Benning, as Bates HRL-000412 through HRL-000437, and the final invoice as HRL-000438 through HRL-000440. The second set of requests for admission read, in part:
Request No. 1: Admit that Exhibit A, Bates-numbered HRL-000412 through HRL-000437, is a genuine copy of text messages exchanged between You and Dana Harlow between March 3, 2025 and April 19, 2025.
Request No. 2: Admit that from March 1, 2025 through April 30, 2025, the telephone number (555) 555-0142 was assigned to a mobile phone You used.
Request No. 3: Admit that You sent each message in Exhibit A attributed to (555) 555-0142.
Request No. 4: Admit that Exhibit A does not omit any text message exchanged between You and Dana Harlow between March 3, 2025 and April 19, 2025.
Request No. 5: Admit that Exhibit B, Bates-numbered HRL-000438 through HRL-000440, is a genuine copy of an invoice You sent to Dana Harlow on April 2, 2025.
Benning admitted Requests 1, 2, 3 and 5 and qualified Request 4, stating that he could not confirm whether messages sent from a second phone appeared in the thread. That single qualification told counsel exactly where the remaining fight was.
What do you do with the responses?
Log each answer against the exhibit it concerns, then act on it. A simple triage:
| Response | What it means | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| Admitted | Genuineness is established for this action | Note it in the foundation column of the exhibit list and the pretrial order |
| No timely response | Deemed admitted under Rule 36(a)(3) | Confirm in writing; expect a possible motion to withdraw |
| Specific denial | Authenticity is contested | Build the foundation and track proof costs for Rule 37(c)(2) |
| Qualified or partial | Part is admitted, part is not | Meet and confer on the qualified part; consider a Rule 36(a)(6) motion |
| Lack of knowledge | Valid only after reasonable inquiry | Check that the answer states the inquiry; challenge it if not |
| Objection | Grounds must be stated | Evaluate, narrow the request or move to determine sufficiency |
A denial of authorship usually points to the next round of proof: subscriber records, other messages from the same number, or the opponent’s own copy of the thread. Our article on subpoenaing phone records explains what carriers can and cannot provide.
How do requests for admission fit with pretrial stipulations?
They make the stipulation easy. Once genuineness has been admitted, a proposed stipulation that the listed exhibits are authentic, while expressly reserving hearsay, relevance and Rule 403 objections, simply records what the case already established. Many teams send the proposed stipulation together with the requests, so opposing counsel can concede authenticity informally instead of answering request by request.
The federal pretrial disclosure rule adds another layer. Under Rule 26(a)(3)(B), objections to disclosed exhibits, other than objections under Federal Rules of Evidence 402 and 403, are generally waived unless made within the time allowed or excused for good cause. Requests for admission resolve authenticity earlier and more definitively, which is useful when a judge’s standing order requires authenticity disputes to be identified well before the final pretrial conference. Record the outcome for each exhibit on the exhibit list so the trial team knows which foundations still need a witness.
What to request, how to respond to qualified answers and whether to file a cost motion are decisions for the supervising attorney under the governing rules and orders. This article is general information, not legal advice.
How CourtBriefly helps
A request for admission is only as precise as the exhibit it describes. Message Extractor ingests the client’s exports, merges duplicates into one thread model and produces a paginated, Bates-stamped, fingerprinted PDF log with an index and a source manifest, so each request can cite an exact Bates range and the copy you attach matches the copy you produced. Deciding what to request remains the attorney’s call; the software prepares the exhibit.
Start freeFree plan, no card
