The client says they were at work. The other side has a screenshot from a family-locator app, the client’s phone has a Google Maps Timeline, and opposing counsel has subpoenaed carrier records. Location evidence is persuasive because maps look objective, and it is easy to overstate for exactly the same reason.

This guide is for litigation teams handling location evidence in civil and family matters. It covers the main kinds of location data and their precision, what changed with Google Maps Timeline, how to preserve and export each source, accuracy and authentication limits, lawful ways to obtain other people’s data, and how to present it. Platform behavior changes often, so confirm current steps on each provider’s own help pages before you rely on them.

What kinds of location data show up in litigation?

Five sources come up most often, and they are not interchangeable. Each measures something different, with different precision, and lives in a different place.

SourceWhat it recordsPrecisionUsual route
Phone location history (Google Maps Timeline, Apple’s Significant Locations & Routes)Visits and routes estimated by the deviceVaries point by point, from meters to much coarserExport by the account holder; discovery
Family-locator apps (for example, Life360)Locations and drives of circle membersDepends on the member’s deviceScreenshots or app records; provider subpoena subject to its retention
Photo metadata (EXIF GPS)Coordinates where a photo was taken, if enabledDevice-dependentOriginal files, not screenshots
Vehicle and fleet telematicsVehicle position, trips, sometimes speedVaries by systemPreservation letter; subpoena; forensic collection
Carrier cell-site recordsWhich cell site or sector handled a connectionA general area, not a pointSubpoena or court order to the carrier

Apple says its Significant Locations & Routes data is synced between devices with end-to-end encryption and cannot be read by Apple, so like Timeline it is a device-side source. For photos, see our guide to photo metadata in litigation; for carriers, see subpoenaing phone records.

What changed with Google Maps Timeline?

Timeline moved from Google’s servers to the user’s devices. In a December 12, 2023 announcement, Google said Timeline would be saved on the device, that backed-up data would be encrypted so no one, including Google, could read it, and that auto-delete would default to three months when the setting is first turned on, down from 18 months. Accounts were moved over through 2024 and 2025, and the web version of Timeline was retired along the way.

Google’s current help page, Manage your Google Maps Timeline, now says Timeline is not available for Maps on a computer. Several details matter for evidence:

  • Each device keeps its own Timeline. Edits or deletions on one device are not reflected on others, so a second phone or tablet may hold a different record.
  • Backups are optional and opt-in per device. Without one, a factory reset or deleting Google Maps deletes that device’s Timeline.
  • Users can edit visits. The help page explains how to change the place and time of a visit, so a Timeline view is not a raw sensor log.
  • Export is on the device. Google describes exporting from Android’s location settings, or from the Google Maps app’s settings on iPhone, where the export is saved as location-history.json. Older guides that point to Google Takeout or the website may be out of date.
  • Other settings can hold location too. Google notes that activity settings may separately store general-area location, for example from an IP address.

How do you preserve and export each kind of location data?

Act early, collect natively where possible, and document every step. Location sources roll off quickly.

  1. Send preservation instructions. Tell the client not to delete history, change auto-delete or reset a device without talking to the attorney, and cover location data in any litigation hold letter.
  2. Export natively. Have the account holder export Timeline or similar history from each device, recording the device, app version, date and who ran it.
  3. Capture apps that cannot export. Life360’s Location & Drive History page says history is available for 2 days on the free plan, 7 days on Silver and 30 days on Gold and Platinum, that there is no in-app export, and recommends screenshots. Capture full scrolls with dates and times visible, promptly.
  4. Collect original photos rather than screenshots or messaging-app copies, which may strip metadata.
  5. Identify vehicle sources. Note make, model, connected services and any fleet vendor, and send preservation letters before routine overwriting.
  6. Hash on arrival. Fingerprint each export and keep the original untouched; see chain of custody for digital evidence.

How accurate is location data, and what can it prove?

Location data proves where a device probably was, within a margin, at a recorded time. It does not prove who was carrying the device, and its margin varies from point to point.

Under open sky, the federal GPS program’s accuracy page says GPS-enabled smartphones are typically accurate to within 4.9 meters (16 feet), with accuracy worsening near buildings, bridges and trees. Positions estimated from Wi-Fi or mobile networks can be much coarser. Cell-site records are different again: the Supreme Court explained in Carpenter v. United States (2018) that the precision of cell-site location information depends on the size of the area a cell site covers, which shrinks where sites are dense.

Before relying on any point, check:

  • The accuracy radius recorded for the point, if the export includes one
  • How the position was determined: GPS, Wi-Fi, mobile network or an inferred place name
  • The time zone of the export and of every exhibit built from it
  • Gaps when the phone was off, in airplane mode or had location disabled
  • Whether visits were edited by the user
  • Whether another source, such as photos, receipts or telematics, corroborates it

Authentication follows the usual paths: a witness with knowledge of how the data was collected, evidence describing the process or system, and in federal courts, certifications for some electronic records under Rule 902(13) and (14). Cell-site analysis is often expert territory.

How do you obtain someone else’s location data lawfully?

Through discovery, subpoena, court order or consent, never by self-help.

Legitimate routes include a request for production asking the other party to export their own history, a subpoena to a provider or carrier subject to its retention and the law that governs it, and, where the dispute justifies it, a court-ordered examination by a neutral examiner under a written protocol. Data a client could see as an ordinary member of a shared family circle is a different situation from data taken from another person’s account, but whether to use it is still the attorney’s call.

How should location evidence be presented?

As a demonstrative map or summary table that points back to the underlying export, which is produced and available for checking. In federal courts, Rule 107 governs illustrative aids and Rule 1006 governs summaries of voluminous records; our guide to timeline demonstrative exhibits covers the difference and the common objections.

  • Draw accuracy radii, not pins that imply false precision.
  • Use a different symbol for each source type, with a legend.
  • Do not connect points into a route unless the data records the route.
  • State the time zone on every page.
  • Cite a Bates page for every point.

Example

In a fictional wage case, Delgado v. Harbor Freightways, the question is when the driver arrived at the yard on March 9, 2026. The team’s summary table, times in Eastern Time:

TimeSourceLocationAccuracyBates
7:42 a.m.Client’s Timeline exportHarbor Freightways yardRadius 12 m (as recorded)DEL-000201
7:45 a.m.Fleet telematics reportTruck 14, ignition on, yardPer vendor documentationDEL-000340
8:10 a.m.Carrier cell-site recordSector serving the port districtGeneral area onlyDEL-000512

The table does not claim more than each source can show. The cell-site row corroborates the general area; the first two rows do the precise work.

How CourtBriefly helps

Location evidence often arrives as a pile of app screenshots, photos and carrier PDFs. Evidence Helper bulk-ingests screenshots, photos and documents, keeps the originals untouched and SHA-256 hashes each one on arrival, extracts text for your team to review and correct, and exports exhibit-numbered, captioned PDFs that list each file’s SHA-256. Each item can be tagged, dated and mapped to the issues in the matter, so the summary table and the underlying records stay connected.

Start freeFree plan, no card